Login to myESAIC Membership
Back

About

The ESAIC is dedicated to supporting professionals in anaesthesiology and intensive care by serving as the hub for development and dissemination of valuable educational, scientific, research, and networking resources.


Back

Congresses

The ESAIC hosts the Euroanaesthesia and Focus Meeting congresses that serve as platforms for cutting-edge science and innovation in the field. These events bring together experts, foster networking, and facilitate knowledge exchange in anaesthesiology, intensive care, pain management, and perioperative medicine. Euroanaesthesia is one of the world’s largest and most influential scientific congresses for anaesthesia professionals. Held annually throughout Europe, our congress is a contemporary event geared towards education, knowledge exchange and innovation in anaesthesia, intensive care, pain and perioperative medicine, as well as a platform for immense international visibility for scientific research.


Back

Professional Growth

The ESAIC's mission is to foster and provide exceptional training and educational opportunities. The ESAIC ensures the provision of robust and standardised examination and certification systems to support the professional development of anaesthesiologists and to ensure outstanding future doctors in the field of anaesthesiology and intensive care.


Back

Research

The ESAIC aims to advance patient outcomes and contribute to the progress of anaesthesiology and intensive care evidence-based practice through research. The ESAIC Clinical Trial Network (CTN), the Academic Contract Research Organisation (A-CRO), the Research Groups and Grants all contribute to the knowledge and clinical advances in the peri-operative setting.


Learn more about the ESAIC Clinical Trial Network (CTN) and the associated studies.

Back

EU Projects

The ESAIC is actively involved as a consortium member in numerous EU funded projects. Together with healthcare leaders and practitioners, the ESAIC's involvement as an EU project partner is another way that it is improving patient outcomes and ensuring the best care for every patient.


Back

Patient Safety

The ESAIC aims to promote the professional role of anaesthesiologists and intensive care physicians and enhance perioperative patient outcomes by focusing on quality of care and patient safety strategies. The Society is committed to implementing the Helsinki Declaration and leading patient safety projects.


Back

Sustainability

To ESAIC is committed to implementing the Glasgow Declaration and drive initiatives towards greater environmental sustainability across anaesthesiology and intensive care in Europe.


Back

Partnerships

The ESAIC works in collaboration with industry, national societies, and specialist societies to promote advancements in anaesthesia and intensive care. The Industry Partnership offers visibility and engagement opportunities for industry participants with ESAIC members, facilitating understanding of specific needs in anaesthesiology and in intensive care. This partnership provides resources for education and avenues for collaborative projects enhancing science, education, and patient safety. The Specialist Societies contribute to high-quality educational opportunities for European anaesthesiologists and intensivists, fostering discussion and sharing, while the National Societies, through NASC, maintain standards, promote events and courses, and facilitate connections. All partnerships collectively drive dialogue, learning, and growth in the anaesthesiology and intensive care sector.


Back

Guidelines

Guidelines play a crucial role in delivering evidence-based recommendations to healthcare professionals. Within the fields of anaesthesia and intensive care, guidelines are instrumental in standardizing clinical practices and enhancing patient outcomes. For many years, the ESAIC has served as a pivotal platform for facilitating continuous advancements, improving care standards and harmonising clinical management practices across Europe.


Back

Publications

With over 40 years of publication history, the EJA (European Journal of Anaesthesiology) has established itself as a highly respected and influential journal in its field. It covers a wide range of topics related to anaesthesiology and intensive care medicine, including perioperative medicine, pain management, critical care, resuscitation, and patient safety.


Back

Membership

Becoming a member of ESAIC implies becoming a part of a vibrant community of nearly 8,000 professionals who exchange best practices and stay updated on the latest developments in anaesthesiology, intensive care and perioperative medicine. ESAIC membership equips you with the tools and resources necessary to enhance your daily professional routine, nurture your career growth, and play an active role in advancing anaesthesiology, intensive care and perioperative medicine.


Membership opportunities
at the ESAIC

Newsletter 2020

Newsletter September 2020: Does BCG vaccination really decrease the risk of COVID-19? A central European perspective

Chief editor note: We continue to publish scientific information related to the current Coronavirus pandemics, keeping our readers updated with the latest news on this topic.

Paweł Piwowarczyk1, Michał Borys1

The Second Department of Anesthesiology and Intensive Therapy, Medical University of Lublin, Lublin, Poland

piwowarczyk.pawel@gmail.com

 

Recently, some authors have suggested that Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccination might be a factor that decreases the risk of infection caused by SARS-CoV-2 .1, 2 According to the results presented by investigators, in countries with a universal BCG vaccination policy, such as Japan and China, the risks of COVID-19 morbidity and mortality are low in comparison with the risks in countries where a universal BCG vaccination policy was never implemented, such as Italy, the United States, and the Netherlands. Moreover, the authors presented experimental data that suggest that BCG vaccination improves immunity against coronavirus. According to this rationale, Australia, the Netherlands, Germany, and the United Kingdom are conducting vaccinations trials among healthcare workers to determine whether the BCG vaccine decreases morbidity and mortality rates associated with COVID-19.

The BCG vaccine is made from a weakened strain of tuberculosis (TB) bacteria, which after subcutaneous injection induces a potent CD8 T-cell response and triggers the immune system to protect against TB. However, the use of BCG vaccination for the prevention of SARS-CoV-2 infection raises biological, demographic, and socio-economic concerns. First, the rationale for and potential benefits of this approach should be carefully balanced against the risk of side effects. According to the literature, BCG vaccination may lead to systemic reactions, including lymphadenitis and disseminated BCG disease, in up to 3% of the population .3 Second, the conjecture that there is a causal relationship between BCG vaccination and decreased COVID-19 morbidity and mortality must be carefully examined. For this purpose, the perspective of Poland is especially valuable, because it is a central European country where a universal BCG-vaccination policy is still active three decades after economic and political transformation; and because in Poland, the spread of and mortality due to COVID-19 are much lower than in many other European regions.

Previous bacterial infections

We believe that the hypothesis regarding the causal relationship between BCG vaccination and decreased morbidity and mortality observed in China and central and eastern European countries in comparison to western European states may be an accidental association. Even if BCG vaccination is associated with improved immunity, this improvement in immunity could be part of a broader hypothesis, namely that early repeated stimulation of human organisms by pathogens is protective against future infections. Microbial exposure in early childhood may play a key role in allowing the immune system to develop protective responses against future pathogens. The prevalence in a particular country of Helicobacter pylori may serve as an indicator of early immune stimulation. In Poland, H. pylori epidemiology in the general population remains relatively high (66.6%) in comparison to Germany and the UK (35.3% and 35.5%, respectively) .4 We should not underestimate the role of repeated bacterial stimulation, including stimulation by H. pylori, in the process of maturation of the cellular immune system CD-8 prior to viral infection .5 We hypothesize that it is not BCG vaccination, but rather early childhood exposure to infections, that is more associated with the enhanced response of the immune system to SARS-CoV-2 infection.

Moreover, to support our hypothesis, some evidence suggests that the risk of allergies and atopy is higher in more developed countries. Allergies and atopy are caused when the immune system is stimulated not by pathogens, but only by foreign proteins (allergens). Studies from the last decade of the previous century showed a considerable difference between West and East Germany with regard to the number of allergies. People born in the West after 1960 had up to a 150% increase in the postwar rate of atopy .6 There might be a significant association between the observed difference in COVID-19 severity in the West and the East (lower in the East) and their rates of atopy

 

Socio-economic aspects

Although biological aspects are essential considerations in the COVID-19 outbreak, socio-economic aspects could be even more important. According to the World Bank data (https://datahelpdesk.worldbank.org/knowledgebase/articles/906519-worldbank-country-and-lending-groups) presented by Miller et al. ,1 Poland is classified as a high-income country; however, wages in Poland are significantly different from those in other developed nations. Because of the behavioural burden of the economic and political transformation period in central-eastern Europe, many social habits in Poland differ from those of the West. Results of a 2014 survey presented by the Polish Public Opinion Research Center showed that only about 2% of people in Poland eat regularly outside their homes (https://www.cbos.pl/SPISKOM.POL/2014/K_115_14.PDF). This statistic represents a huge difference in comparison to the United States, where approximately 60% of the population eat commonly outside their homes (https://news.gallup.com/poll/201710/americans-dining-frequency-little-changed-2008.aspx). As in the United States, many western Europeans dine-in bars and restaurants daily. According to statista.com, almost 12 million Germans eat in restaurants often. Interestingly, during the COVID-19 outbreak, restaurants and coffee houses were closed later in Italy than churches were, in some way showing the importance of dining institutions in the community. Poland’s borders were closed to foreigners earlier than restaurants were closed in Italy, even though Italy was the first source of the pandemic in Europe.

The ageing of the population in the majority of developed countries is also relevant because of the higher risk of mortality in elders from COVID-19. The median age in Poland is 39.4 years, in comparison to Italy and Germany, where it is 45 and 46.3, respectively. Moreover, the proportion of the population over 65 years old in Poland is rather low (15%) in comparison to that of Italy and Germany (22.1% and 21.7%, respectively). Hence, the number of nursing home beds is higher in western Europe. Approximately 70 thousand beds are available in Poland (38 million citizens), but 642 thousand in France and 548 thousand in the UK (67 and 66 million citizens, respectively) (https://gateway.euro.who.int/en/hfa-explorer/#fDgBcquLtK). When COVID-19 occurs in such facilities, which has happened in many places, the mortality ratio is very high.

The last issue we found relevant to the rate of the spread of COVID-19 concerns democracy, respect for rules, and personal freedom. Here in Poland, most institutions and even country borders were closed when the first cases of COVID-19 were identified. From the early days of the pandemic, visiting parks, forests, or other recreational areas, as well as travelling without an important reason, was not allowed. Students moved out of dormitories to prepare these places for quarantine. Moreover, public transportation between cities was cancelled. Similar actions were carried out in the Czech Republic and Slovakia, and in each of these countries, deaths due to COVID-19 did not exceed several hundred. In our opinion, in more mature democratic nations, these actions are not as easy to carry out and take a longer time, and public debate over them is essential. However, due to these rapid and severe administrative operations, the spread of COVID-19 was significantly reduced.

 

Conclusion

To conclude, BCG vaccination might have played some role in the alleviation of the COVID-19 outbreak, but its role may be overestimated. In most countries with a universal BCG vaccination policy, the threat of TB is real and associated with a higher overall chance of microbial exposure. Medical policymakers should carefully assess the risk and benefits of BCG vaccination and ensure that the standard of evidence is met.

 

References

  1. Miller A, Reandelar MJ, Fasciglione K, et al. 2020 medRxiv doi:10.1101/2020.03.24.20042937.
  2. Hegarty PK, Kamat AM, Zafirakis H, Dinardo A. 2020 cc doi: 10.13140/RG.2.2.35948.10880
  3. Aishwarya Venkataraman, Michael Yusuff et al. Vaccine,2015;33:5470–5474. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2015.07.103.
  4. Hooi J.K.Y., Lai W.Y., Ng WK, et al.. Gastroenterology,2017;153:420-429. doi: 10.1053/j.gastro.2017.04.022.
  5. Kronsteiner B, Bassaganya-Riera J, Philipson N, Hontecillas R.. Gut Microbes, 2014;5:357-362. doi: 10.4161/gmic.28899.
  6. Wichmann H.E. (1997) Postwar Increase of Allergies in the West, but not in the East of Germany?. In: Ring J., Behrendt H., Vieluf D. (eds) New Trends in Allergy IV. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-60419-5_3.

 

More Newsletter Articles

Visit our Euroanaesthesia 2020 Website for more news on everything related to the virtual congress.

Visit our COVID-19 Resource Hub for other news and resources.